Bagel Cafe – Bay Shore, NY: Hours, Menu & Directions

Opening hours

Eastern Time

Opening hours have not been published for this bakery yet. Call (631) 968-9050 to check today's hours. Know the hours? Send them to us.

Tap for directions

134 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Google Maps Apple Maps Waze Bing Maps

Address134 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Phone(631) 968-9050

StyleBagel shop

CountySuffolk County

Time zoneEastern Time

From city center1.3 mi south

About Bagel Cafe

You will find Bagel Cafe at 134 W Main St in Bay Shore, roughly 1.3 mi from downtown Bay Shore, heading south. You will also find it under bakery cafés in our directory.

Our Bay Shore directory counts 10 bakeries in total. If you want to compare, Cookie Kneads sits 0.1 mi from here.

We have not been able to confirm a full weekly schedule for Bagel Cafe yet, so calling ahead at (631) 968-9050 is the safest bet. Bakeries often sell out of popular items by early afternoon.

This is one of 13 locations of the same brand in our directory.

At a glance

Listed as	Bagel shop and Bakery café
Bakeries in Bay Shore	10
Nearest bakery	0.1 mi
Brand locations	13

Suggest an edit

What to order

Typical items at a bagel shop like this one — the bakery's own selection may differ.

Full menu

Classic bagels

Pumpernickel bagelDark, rye-based bagel deepened with molasses, offering an earthy, slightly sour flavor and a tight, chewy crumb.
Egg bagelGolden-yellow bagel enriched with eggs for a softer, richer crumb and a faintly sweet, brioche-like flavor.
Plain bagelBoiled-then-baked ring with a shiny, blistered crust and dense, chewy interior; a clean base for any spread or sandwich.
Everything bagelTopped with sesame, poppy seed, dried garlic, onion and coarse salt for a savory, crunchy crust in every bite.

Specialty bagels

Blueberry bagelPurple-tinted dough studded with dried blueberries, sweet and fruity; usually paired with honey or strawberry cream cheese.
French toast bagelSweet bagel brushed with cinnamon sugar and a touch of maple flavor, tasting like diner French toast in ring form.
Asiago bagelBaked under a crust of shredded Asiago cheese that crisps into lacy, sharp-tasting edges around the chewy ring.
Jalapeño cheddar bagelDough folded with diced jalapeños and baked under melted cheddar, bringing mild heat and salty, tangy cheese.

Cream cheese & spreads

Strawberry cream cheesePink, fruity spread made with real strawberry pieces, light and sweet against a plain or blueberry bagel.
Tofu scallion spreadPlant-based spread whipped from tofu and seasoned with scallions and lemon; a dairy-free stand-in with a similar tang.
Whitefish saladSmoked whitefish flaked and mixed with mayonnaise and celery; creamy, smoky and a classic New York deli spread.
Plain cream cheeseThick layer of whipped cream cheese; cool, tangy and the standard topping for a bagel fresh from the oven.